A roof replacement price covers taking the old roof off down to the wood, the layers that keep water out (ice-and-water shield, underlayment, flashing, drip edge and vents), the new shingles, the permit, haul-away and a magnetic nail sweep. It stops at three edges: wood that turns out to be rotten once the shingles are off, which is priced per sheet; work that belongs to another trade, like gutters, skylight units or solar panels; and a short list of things you do yourself before the crew arrives.
Below, every item that usually shows up when people ask what is included in roof replacement is sorted by how it gets paid for, because that is the question behind the question. Most arguments after a re-roof are about an item that one side thought was in the price and the other side did not.
Four ways an item can sit on a roofing bid
Each box is a different kind of money, and a good bid tells you which box every item lives in.
In the price you sign
- Tear-off of every old layer, down to the deck, and the dumpster to haul it
- Ice-and-water shield at the eaves and in the valleys
- Synthetic underlayment over the rest of the deck
- New drip edge, new flashing and new boots at chimneys, walls, vents and skylights
- Intake and exhaust vents sized to the attic
- Starter, shingles and ridge cap from one maker: GAF, Owens Corning or IKO
- The permit and the village inspection
- Magnetic nail sweep, a walkthrough with you, the warranty paperwork
One number, fixed when you sign.
Priced only if the crew finds it
- Plywood or OSB sheets that are soft, rotted or delaminated
- Old spaced plank boards that need new sheathing before shingles can be nailed
- A rotted strip of fascia behind the old drip edge
A unit rate written into the estimate, used only when the deck is open and you have seen the photos.
A separate line or another trade
- Gutters and downspouts
- Siding repairs where the roof meets a wall
- A new skylight unit (its flashing is in the first box)
- Solar panels: detach and reset by a licensed solar contractor
- Attic insulation and air sealing
- Chimney masonry, crown or tuckpointing
Its own price, its own decision, ideally the same week.
Yours to do
- Cars out of the driveway the night before
- Cover what is stored in the attic
- Call your TV provider about the satellite dish
- Pets and kids away from the drop zone on tear-off day
No charge, about an evening of work. The full night-before list is here.
The first box is our published scope for a residential roof replacement. Other contractors draw the lines in different places, which is the whole reason to ask.
How the "if found" items get priced fairly
Nobody can see the deck through the shingles. A soft spot you can feel when you walk the roof, or a stain on the attic side, gives a hint, but the real count happens on tear-off day. That is why rotten wood is the one item on an honest bid that cannot be a fixed number.
What can be fixed is the rate. Get the price per sheet of decking written into the estimate before you sign, and ask the crew to photograph the bad sheets before they go into the dumpster. Then the phone call on tear-off day is a count, not a negotiation. A bid that says "decking as needed" with no rate leaves you agreeing to a price while the house is open to the sky.
The other three lines on the checklist are the ones we see missing most often when a homeowner shows us a competing bid. The guide to reading a roofing estimate covers the rest of the paperwork.
Bid wording, and the question to ask about each phrase
Estimates are written in a short trade language. These six phrases show up on bids all over the north and northwest suburbs. None of them is wrong on its own; each one is a place where the price can quietly shrink or grow.
- Replace damaged decking as needed
- How much per sheet, who decides a sheet is bad, and will I see a photo of each one?
- Flashing where required
- Which flashing is new: step flashing at the walls, the chimney, the pipe boots? Is anything being reused?
- Architectural shingle, color to be selected
- Which manufacturer and which product line? Two shingles from the same maker can carry different wind ratings and warranties.
- Ventilation per code
- What goes in at the soffit, what goes out at the ridge, and do the old box vents come out and get patched with new decking?
- Permit if required
- Who pulls it, and is the fee in this price? Village rules differ, so the answer belongs on paper.
- Clean up all debris
- Where does the dumpster sit, how often is the yard swept with a magnet, and are the gutters flushed of grit at the end?
On our side, the answers are written into the estimate, and the six steps of our process show when you get each one.
What stays outside the price, and why that is usually fine
A roofing price that tried to cover everything on the outside of a house would be impossible to compare. Gutters are a good example. The drip edge at the bottom of the roof is ours and sits on every bid. The gutter below it is a different system with its own measurements, and on a 25-year-old house it may have years left or none. We install seamless gutters as their own line so you can say yes or no to them without it touching the roof number.
Skylights work the same way. The metal flashing kit around each one is part of the roof. The glass unit is a separate product, and replacing an old one while the shingles around it are already off saves cutting into a new roof a few years later. Solar panels have to come off before tear-off and go back on after. That is a job for a licensed solar contractor, and booking them early is what keeps your roof from sitting half finished.
Insulation is the item people are most often surprised to find outside the price. We balance the vents because the shingle maker's warranty depends on airflow. Adding insulation is a different trade.
If a storm is the reason for the new roof
The list of what is included does not change because hail caused the damage. What changes is that the insurance carrier writes its own estimate, and that estimate lists items line by line too: tear-off, underlayment, drip edge, flashing, vents, shingles. If an item your roof needs is not on their list, the carrier decides whether to add it. Nobody can promise you that it will.
Our part is documenting the damage with photos, measuring the roof and writing a code-compliant estimate. For the claim itself, our partner, the licensed Illinois public adjuster State Adjusting Services, can represent you with the insurer. Illinois law does not let a roofing contractor negotiate a claim, so be careful with anyone at the door who offers to. More on how this works is on our insurance claim page.
Questions about the edges of the price
Is the permit part of the roof replacement price?
With us, yes. We pull the permit and schedule the village inspection, and the installed price ranges we publish already include it. Ask any other bidder the same question in writing, because some leave the permit to the homeowner.
Are gutters included in a roof replacement?
No. Gutters are their own system and their own line on the estimate. The drip edge that sits above them is part of the roof. If your gutters are old, replacing them in the same week is cheaper than taking the new drip edge apart later.
Are pipe boots and flashing new, or reused?
On our roofs the flashing and the rubber boots around plumbing vents are new. On any bid, look for the words reuse existing or as needed next to flashing and ask which pieces are new.
Does a roof replacement include attic insulation?
No. We balance the attic ventilation because the shingle warranty depends on it, but adding insulation or sealing the attic floor is work for an insulation contractor, priced separately.
Does a new roof include new skylights?
The flashing around each skylight is part of the roof. The skylight unit itself is a separate decision with its own price. An old skylight is easiest to replace while the shingles around it are off, so decide before the crew starts.
What happens if the crew finds rotten wood?
The crew replaces the soft or rotted sheets before anything goes on top, at the per-sheet rate written in your estimate, and you hear about it the same day. That rate is the one number worth agreeing on before you sign.
Related reading: what happens under the new shingles, layer by layer and roof replacement cost in the Chicago suburbs.
Holding a bid and not sure which box an item belongs in? Book a free inspection or call (866) 992-2982, Monday to Friday, 7 AM to 7 PM, and Saturday and Sunday, 9 AM to 5 PM. We are a family-owned roofer in Lincolnshire working across the north and northwest Chicago suburbs.
